Why You Should Care About The New Facebook Reply Button

Why You Should Care About The New Facebook Reply Button

By: Guest
April 16, 2013

understanding facebook reply buttonRecently, Facebook announced a significant update—the release of the Reply Button. And while Facebook has had a tumultuous relationship with Wall Street, Zuckerberg and his team are attempting to build confidence within the financial industry. That’s why they’re going to great lengths to develop solutions, features, and products that help brand marketers to use the platform effectively.

Facebook wants brands and marketers to be successful. So, let’s take a closer look at how the Reply Button will help you, the marketer, be more successful on the Facebook platform.

Where Did the Reply Button Come From?

Community Managers far and wide have been requesting a feature like the Reply Button for quite a while. They wanted the ability to leave threaded replies, directly addressing those who leave comments on their Pages.

what is facebook reply button

Facebook conducted months of testing, and the feature will be rolled out to all Pages with more than 10K followers by July 10, 2013.

Let’s take a closer look at its functionality.

What Does the Reply Button Do?

  • Page Administrators will be able to respond directly to each Fan Comment. That is, they’ll be able to address each user directly in an individual thread, rather than tagging users with the @ symbol within a general comment thread.
  • Comments and replies will be prioritized according to engagement and relevancy. Comments and replies with the MOST engagement will surface to the top of the post.
  • Furthermore, comments and replies that are relevant to each Fan (meaning that the Social Graph of each user will be taking into account) will rise to the top, giving a unique view of a brand’s Page to each Fan.
  • The “Reply” feature is only available to Facebook Pages, not Profiles, and it can easily be turned off by a Page Administrator, if necessary.

What Does the Reply Button Mean For Marketers?

facebook reply button and marketers

1:1 Engagement

Although it’s still in a public forum, the Reply Button finally allows brands to develop that 1:1 relationship with their fans that they’ve been looking to do. Replying in a threaded format is much more effective in keeping the conversation going than tagging someone with an @ symbol.

Think of this function as being used similarly to the Reply function that Twitter offers. If a brand replies directly to a user’s tweet, that reply tweet doesn’t show up in the Twitter feed of all followers, it can only be seen by all followers if they visit the brand’s profile directly. And even then, it notifies only the user that was called out in the tweet.

The Reply Button on Facebook has a similar purpose. Brands can now respond to one particular comment, and the reply will only notify one fan. This gives brands a direct connection with their fans and specifically addresses each comment. Each comment, complaint or concern can be responded to in a personalized setting.

And, while this new feature will become a staple for Community Managers, it will be particularly helpful for brands during a social crisis or around sensitive topics. Rather than notifying the hundreds that may be commenting within a particular post, these replies will only notify one user. This might help to slow the virality of negative conversations—this is something all brands should take note of.


The new Reply Button will provide a unique view of a brand’s Page for each user. Because comments are going to be weighted by volume of activity, and more importantly, your Social Graph, this function serves to make the ongoing conversations much more relevant.

For example, if Orbitz asks its fans what their favorite beach destination is, and a handful of my friends respond, I will see their comments at the top of the post instead of other random Facebook users who might have replied. This is huge for travel brands, as opinions and recommendations from friends are incredibly influential when it comes to destination or purchase decisions.

It’s still unknown how much the reply activities will affect the EdgeRank algorithm, but it’s safe to say that brands should be excited that the Social Graph of each fan will be taken more heavily into account.

New Layer of Insight

The Reply Button offers a new layer of analytics and insights that marketers will need to take into account. As brands begin replying to users, and users begin replying to each other, Page Administrators will be able to see which types of comments are generating the most responses.

If a hotel brand asks its fans, “How was your Easter weekend?” and a fan comments about how much they enjoyed the brunch menu at a particular location, and that then generates a significant number of replies, then the hotel brand will know that a specialized brunch menu is something they should offer more often.

Digging through the new set of metrics that the Reply Button will provide might seem a bit daunting at first. It will undoubtedly create more work for Community Managers and Analysts, but it will ultimately provide an important layer of insight that social marketers can use to develop content that’s more effective and more engaging.

Marketers, how has your workflow changed with the addition of the Reply button on Facebook?

erica mcclennyErica McClenny is the Senior Vice President of Client Services at Expion, a social media management system company that helps businesses connect with customers through engagement. Her passion lies in educating executives about the functions and nuances of social media channels, while collaborating with marketing and IT departments to build successful strategies. Follow her on Twitter: @ericamcclenny and learn more about Expion’s social software at www.expion.com.

Originally posted on Tnooz by Erica McClenny, Expion’s SVP of Client Services and Viewpoint Contributor at Tnooz.

Image: channelship via Compfight cc

  • It was a great idea. Then they combined it with comment ranking, which threw everything in to a great big mess. I ended up turning it off for my page, as it put discussions way out of order.

  • ShellyKramer

    I can see why you’d do that. I hate things that make it more annoying rather than more streamlined.

  • Great review. Such product improvements by Facebook will bring good results with an increased conversation rate. New analytic tools can be developed making use of this great feature, so that it offers some meaningful data for the marketers.

  • I LOVE the reply button. Got it on my personal profile and it makes responding to people so much easier. Biggest nit about it is that it isn’t enabled via mobile yet, so reading comments that way is kind of a mess. That’s a big issue.

  • Amy, Expion was happy to see it show up in the API at least for pages. I haven’t seen any updates for mobile integration but I’m sure it’s coming soon. Now I’m curious so I’m going to ask them on a time frame.

  • They need to allow a tab at the start of the comments like Disqus. So you can veiw top ranked or most recent.

  • Pingback: The New MySpace: JT’s Folly()

  • Pingback: 12 Tips and Tools for Better Facebook Management()

  • Pingback: 12 Tips and Tools for Better Facebook Management | Million Dollar Business Blog()

  • Pingback: 12 Tips and Tools for Better Facebook Management » eHow TO...()

  • Well, I’ll stick my toe in and try it out but there have been so many Facebook changes it sometimes seem easier to stick with the basics & not worry about the rest of it

  • ShellyKramer

    I think that’s a dangerous standpoint, but of course, each to his or her own. When it comes to social media channels, they ALL change on a regular basis, and to not expect that might be somewhat short sighted. If you’re going to use the channels for fun, it’s one thing. But if you’re going to use them for business and not try and stay abreast of the changes, there’s a chance your efforts (or your money) might be wasted. Which is why we write about things like this. But again, there’s no right or wrong way, only the way that works for you. Thanks for coming by, Tina :))

  • Shelly, I understand but at least on LinkedIn which is how I found you, I’m not seeing interaction, just lots of people posting content … which must be for the inbound links

  • Pingback: Virtual Assistants for companies & busy people()